{"result_id":"R-d744378a9776dfdb","execution_key":"d744378a9776dfdb51b4cc32261c96503486faf2da5ad4f291cf27a75f086db4","execution_state":{"article":{"oldid":1361634710,"html_sha256":"7727a8a109aa05f51aa83e2bad5db2acdd7a508b7b6b225d98b626330e937cef"},"claims":["W1","W2","W3","W4","W5","W6","W7","W8"],"sources":{"W1":["d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","4bfff26b053e1b138c73ab3e81bde00f612918e7be45d0de6a623724a620dade"],"W2":["3a5aaa17de513d42b82d0cfc17af70bab8c47926f8c05cc59ea69d171499b9df","4bfff26b053e1b138c73ab3e81bde00f612918e7be45d0de6a623724a620dade","d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","3930213bb30975ed5b9bf440d83a3a160dd698249a8beb71708c1adf0928fdc6"],"W3":["d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","4bfff26b053e1b138c73ab3e81bde00f612918e7be45d0de6a623724a620dade","3930213bb30975ed5b9bf440d83a3a160dd698249a8beb71708c1adf0928fdc6"],"W4":["d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","4bfff26b053e1b138c73ab3e81bde00f612918e7be45d0de6a623724a620dade"],"W5":["4bfff26b053e1b138c73ab3e81bde00f612918e7be45d0de6a623724a620dade","d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","3930213bb30975ed5b9bf440d83a3a160dd698249a8beb71708c1adf0928fdc6"],"W6":["3930213bb30975ed5b9bf440d83a3a160dd698249a8beb71708c1adf0928fdc6","4bfff26b053e1b138c73ab3e81bde00f612918e7be45d0de6a623724a620dade","d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3"],"W7":["4bfff26b053e1b138c73ab3e81bde00f612918e7be45d0de6a623724a620dade","d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3"],"W8":["d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","4bfff26b053e1b138c73ab3e81bde00f612918e7be45d0de6a623724a620dade"]},"policies":{"Wikidata Notability":"f20e758ff2994b215e5e9e602f6235b367efed80d10bf13ed5f46062996bedf2","Wikipedia:Conflict of interest":"2015e8d1f322a5ff45d5d012fd2057bd1f16b50292fe5a57493186c5406ec4c0","Wikipedia:Neutral point of view":"a147ed212b0f9d326cc75966b6b94b7081674678f3c2624a47c497ed0ef880e9","Wikipedia:No original research":"1a616733eb0b5a8ebc8470ced6b8c5ef895dcde69f929cea5b5acaf05933e818","Wikipedia:Notability":"b221d8631f7e9e4307cc6919fa5587ec0db95b859f34072fb3a1a44f750fc31a","Wikipedia:Reliable sources":"0051b5ffa0fa21afd9be5e4133d7ffd0640b510b2a1e0b06fb602e09f91ee048","Wikipedia:Verifiability, not truth":"3c428170de3a8947ab83ec45296c023a6a2e685b3a341c57580bc59e4fed23e5","Wikipedia:Verifiability":"8fc4bec260cb813bee8e15871efc3d2431fb56626e9cf01f54111daa1c669f57"},"s7":"c6efe98d63863076a048aff698fe9d45abba6175be037e05fe43c9084e11d7d2","ontology_rules":"2026-10-25c: disagreements settle by the constructs ruling; the case follows ρ","protocol":"gnosis-S3/0.6","reader":"anthropic:claude-sonnet-5-5/gnosis-S3/0.6/direct/schema","reader_mode":"live","calibration":"uncalibrated","service":"0.19.7","tier":"commission"},"normalization":"NFC; ᾿ ᾽ ’ ʼ ' unified; curly and angle quotes unified; whitespace collapsed","pinned":{"title":"Sophistical Refutations","oldid":1361634710,"url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Sophistical_Refutations&oldid=1361634710","retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:37.086Z","from":"store","html_sha256":"7727a8a109aa05f51aa83e2bad5db2acdd7a508b7b6b225d98b626330e937cef"},"execution_contract":{"sources":"the sources each sentence cites (footnotes and classical pointers), fetched once and hashed; and, for every sentence, at most 4 of the sources the article cites elsewhere that bear on it, marked \"elsewhere in the article\" (S3 rule 1); an uncited sentence is read against those alone","sent_to_reader":"the passages of each source that bear on the claim (classical chapters whole), with a code-computed structure summary; quotations are checked against the full text","search_scope":"the sources the article cites (the disclosed field B); and the Crimson Hexagonal Archive by its own procedure (EA-NEGONT-02 v0.9 §3.4): every deposit text and every blog post the blog–deposit map does not assign to a deposit, scanned for the entity's strings (the article's title and the names its lead gives) at D, R and O; one citation hop from the deposits admitted by reading, screened by string; admission by two reading passes","archive_release":{"archive_commit":"0f9f7b546e073fbe7644a18648b9db0c8f9247fd","registry_sha256":"9f835f1aa71e5fd5e46dfde8c72b80d953f133d768b6e37340d30696474c3843","citation_graph_sha256":"b1fdd083c109a303130092ecc7a2779e2f54afe951defd209129640b535ae082","traverse_script_sha256":"83737905f980ae5e70b075fc0112cd9b0e3f5af2ef769f4e646d6e388733d2ff"},"publication":"the entity's /non row is public (CC BY 4.0) at https://www.alexanarch.org/non/sophistical-refutations/ once landed: the opening contributes to the opened Wikipedia","execution_budget":"model spending for the archive's consultation stops at $0.71 (each stage's estimated cost × 1.5, never above its line), and $0.71 of it is held for the construction while the reading runs; passes beyond it are recorded as not run, and the row is composed from what was read, marked","deliverables":{"reading":"the reading dossier: the traversal, the admitted deposits with their readings, the archive and field ledgers with every claim's quote checked, and both ontology readings with the determination of the case and ρ (in the landing tree)","construction":"the knowledge object, its compression and the field-only arm, the delta read against T, and the reverse entailment audit (the /non row)"},"context_rule":"passages first; when a reading pass reports that the passages lack what a judgment needs, the passages are widened and the claim is read again, once","retrieval_budget":{"max_sources":100,"max_bytes_per_source":5000000},"stopping_rule":"every cited source fetched or recorded unavailable"},"evidence":[{"claim":{"id":"W1","section":"lead","text":"Sophistical Refutations (Greek: Σοφιστικοὶ Ἔλεγχοι, romanized: Sophistikoi Elenchoi; Latin: De Sophisticis Elenchis) is a text in Aristotle's Organon in which he identified twelve or thirteen fallacies.","text_sha256":"c812b939172a432c362ced64d2fd446847ba6b774c99c3aec8599bc0f1643a81","footnotes":[],"pointers":[],"cited":false},"ledger_key":"8faea0e015e4eabcbd58223e20a571a39ca0285f5a79879f3574f92d60914adc","sources":[{"ref":"S1","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-SEP_Refutation-1","citation":"Aristotle; Translated by W. A. Pickard-Cambridge. \"On Sophistical Refutations\". Retrieved 2020-12-19.","url":"http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt","final_url":"https://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:38.335Z","raw_sha256":"d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","text_sha256":"d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","availability":"fetched","first_cited_at":"W4","located":"elsewhere in the article","text_chars":130254},{"ref":"S2","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-SEP_AristotleLogic-2","citation":"Edward N. Zalta, ed. (18 March 2000). \"Aristotle's Logic, < Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy>\". Retrieved 2020-12-19.","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic","final_url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic/","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:39.078Z","raw_sha256":"f8f652676469b11b60256290204e2ebf81ed3d00ff3afcacf98d8e1063a0f365","text_sha256":"4bfff26b053e1b138c73ab3e81bde00f612918e7be45d0de6a623724a620dade","availability":"fetched","first_cited_at":"W4","located":"elsewhere in the article","text_chars":94132}],"passes":[{"model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","reading":{"claim_id":"W1","innocent_reading":"The sentence is a lead definition: the work is a text in the Organon (S2 lists On Sophistical Refutations among the Organon treatises) in which Aristotle classifies fallacies, giving a count of twelve or thirteen. The hedged count reflects scholarly disagreement over how to tally the types, and the lead may rest on the body of the article rather than on S1/S2 for the number.","innocent_reading_fails_at":"The number twelve or thirteen: neither S1 nor S2 passages supplied state a count of twelve or thirteen. S1 shows six language-dependent kinds are not enumerated in the passages sent, plus 'seven kinds' independent of language (partial list), which would sum to thirteen only if the language group has six; S1's passage truncates before settling the sum. The 'twelve or thirteen' hedge is not given by S1 or S2 in the passages supplied.","support":["partially-supported","unresolved"],"support_source":["elsewhere in the article"],"spans":[{"quote":"On Sophistical Refutations","source_ref":"S2","role":"support"},{"quote":"Of fallacies, on the other hand, that are independent of language there are seven kinds","source_ref":"S1","role":"scope"},{"quote":"On Sophistical Refutations is a final section, or an appendix, to the Topics","source_ref":"S2","role":"support"},{"quote":"identified twelve or thirteen fallacies","source_ref":"claim","role":"contrast"}],"paraphrase":{"defensible":"On Sophistical Refutations is one of the logical treatises grouped as the Organon; in it Aristotle classifies sophistical (apparent) refutations, distinguishing fallacies that depend on language from seven kinds that do not.","deltas":[{"sentence_says":"a text in Aristotle's Organon","source_says":"The ancient commentators grouped together several of Aristotle's treatises under the title Organon and regarded them as comprising his logical works: ... On Sophistical Refutations","kind":"none","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":null},{"sentence_says":"he identified twelve or thirteen fallacies","source_says":"fallacies ... independent of language there are seven kinds (the language-dependent group is cut off in the supplied passages)","kind":"scope","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":4},{"sentence_says":"identified ... fallacies","source_says":"Aristotle's remark that he is classing arguments that appear to be refutations; S2: arguments that 'only apparently establish their conclusions'","kind":"term changed","measure":"primary-text adequacy","lambda":4}]},"divided":[{"phrase":"twelve or thirteen fallacies","readings":["The count of fallacy types in the classification (six or so language-dependent plus seven independent, giving thirteen, or twelve on a different tally)","A count of modes of apparent refutation, which Aristotle also presents as breaches of the definition of refutation (S1 Part 6), a different grouping than a list of fallacies"]}],"attributization":{"operation":"Aristotle classifies the sources of apparent refutation, dividing them into those depending on language and those independent of it, and tests each against the definition of refutation.","attribute":"identified twelve or thirteen fallacies (a numerical property of the text)","value":"partial","reason":"The sentence compresses a classificatory act into a count; the division into two families and the reduction to breaches of the definition of refutation do not survive.","surviving":["the text is concerned with fallacies","the text sorts them into kinds"],"lost":["the two-family division (language-dependent vs. independent)","the reduction of all fallacies to ignorance of what refutation is","the exact tally, which the supplied passages do not fix"],"converted":true},"retained_authority":{"value":"mixed","evidence":"The existence and type of the classification are retained; the count is presented as fixed (with a hedge) though the sources supplied do not settle it and the tally depends on how modes are grouped (Part 6 offers an alternative single-principle reduction).","revision_required":"Attribute the count explicitly (e.g. 'which scholars count as twelve or thirteen') and note the division into language-dependent and language-independent fallacies."},"invitation":{"codes":["not-applicable"],"qualification":null,"closure":null,"note":"The source holds nothing out for the audience's judgment in a way the lead sentence could preserve or foreclose."},"alternatives":["The count appears in the article body or in other sources (e.g. a different edition or commentary) and is supported there, only not in the passages supplied.","The 'twelve or thirteen' hedge is an editorial reconciliation of differing tallies of the language-dependent group (six vs. five) and is supported by Pickard-Cambridge's own enumeration if the full text is read."],"correction_pathway":"Retrieve S1 Part 4's full enumeration of language-dependent fallacies (ambiguity, amphiboly, combination, division, accent, form of expression) and sum with the seven independent kinds; check S2 or other cited sources for a stated count. If six plus seven, the sentence's 'thirteen' is supported and 'twelve' would need a source.","five_part":{"support":"S2 supports the work's place in the Organon and that it is an appendix to the Topics; S1 supports a division of fallacies into language-dependent and seven independent kinds.","changes":"The sentence adds a specific count (twelve or thirteen) not stated in the supplied passages and drops the two-family division.","alternative":"The count follows from S1's own enumeration (six plus seven) and the 'or' marks a known scholarly variance in tallying.","status":"Organon membership: verified. Seven independent kinds: verified. Language-dependent count and the 'twelve' variant: unresolved.","revision":"Full S1 Part 4 enumeration or a source stating the tally would settle the count."},"needs_more_context":true,"policy":[{"clause":"No original research: describing cited material in one's own words while retaining the substance is permitted; a specific figure must be present in or derivable from the source.","status":"applicable"},{"clause":"Lead sentences may summarise body content; support can lie elsewhere in the article.","status":"inferred"}],"notes":"The passages sent truncate S1 Part 4 before the list of language-dependent fallacies (offsets 6000-9000 missing, and the enumeration of the seven independent kinds is cut off), so the count of twelve or thirteen cannot be checked here. Wider S1 passages from Part 4 are needed. The Greek/Latin titles and romanization are not testable against S1/S2."},"validation":{"ok":true,"breaches":[{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":1,"detail":"quoted span stands in S1 but not in the passages sent","quote":"Of fallacies, on the other hand, that are independent of language there are seven kinds"},{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":2,"detail":"quoted span stands in S2 but not in the passages sent","quote":"On Sophistical Refutations is a final section, or an appendix, to the Topics"}]},"usage":null},{"model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","reading":{"claim_id":"W1","support":["partially-supported","unresolved"],"support_source":["elsewhere in the article","none"],"spans":[{"quote":"On Sophistical Refutations is a final section, or an appendix, to the Topics","source_ref":"S2","role":"support"},{"quote":"Aristotle's study of sophistical arguments is contained in On Sophistical Refutations","source_ref":"S2","role":"support"},{"quote":"Of fallacies, on the other hand, that are independent of language there are seven kinds","source_ref":"S1","role":"scope"},{"quote":"identified twelve or thirteen fallacies","source_ref":"claim","role":"scope"}],"paraphrase":{"defensible":"On Sophistical Refutations is a work by Aristotle, traditionally counted among the logical treatises of the Organon (and attached to the Topics), that classifies the kinds of sophistical argument and their fallacies.","deltas":[]},"attributization":{"operation":"Aristotle classifies sophistical arguments by the number and kinds of sources of apparent refutation, in a text conventionally grouped into the Organon.","value":"partial","converted":true},"retained_authority":{"value":"mixed"},"needs_more_context":true,"notes":"The Organon membership and the work's subject are supported by S2, but the 'twelve or thirteen' count is not verifiable from the passages supplied (S1 shows 'seven kinds' of non-linguistic fallacies and a language-dependent group of unseen size, with only part of the chapter listing shown), and the count's definitional basis (thirteen vs. twelve, depending on whether one fallacy is merged) needs the full Part 4 enumeration and a secondary source on the counting."},"validation":{"ok":true,"breaches":[{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":0,"detail":"quoted span stands in S2 but not in the passages sent","quote":"On Sophistical Refutations is a final section, or an appendix, to the Topics"},{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":2,"detail":"quoted span stands in S1 but not in the passages sent","quote":"Of fallacies, on the other hand, that are independent of language there are seven kinds"}]},"usage":null}],"verdict":{"status":"concordant","support":["partially-supported","unresolved"],"attributization":"partial","attributization_converted":true,"retained_authority":"mixed","invitation_differs":{"status":"prospective; recorded, not counted","readings":[["not-applicable"],[]]}},"tuple":{"ω":"Aristotle classifies the sources of apparent refutation, dividing them into those depending on language and those independent of it, and tests each against the definition of refutation.","w":"Sophistical Refutations (Greek: Σοφιστικοὶ Ἔλεγχοι, romanized: Sophistikoi Elenchoi; Latin: De Sophisticis Elenchis) is a text in Aristotle's Organon in which he identified twelve or thirteen fallacies.","δ":"lead statement","G_W":[{"clause":"No original research: describing cited material in one's own words while retaining the substance is permitted; a specific figure must be present in or derivable from the source.","status":"applicable"},{"clause":"Lead sentences may summarise body content; support can lie elsewhere in the article.","status":"inferred"}],"Δ_D":[{"sentence_says":"a text in Aristotle's Organon","source_says":"The ancient commentators grouped together several of Aristotle's treatises under the title Organon and regarded them as comprising his logical works: ... On Sophistical Refutations","kind":"none","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":null},{"sentence_says":"he identified twelve or thirteen fallacies","source_says":"fallacies ... independent of language there are seven kinds (the language-dependent group is cut off in the supplied passages)","kind":"scope","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":4},{"sentence_says":"identified ... fallacies","source_says":"Aristotle's remark that he is classing arguments that appear to be refutations; S2: arguments that 'only apparently establish their conclusions'","kind":"term changed","measure":"primary-text adequacy","lambda":4}],"Δ_C":["the two-family division (language-dependent vs. independent)","the reduction of all fallacies to ignorance of what refutation is","the exact tally, which the supplied passages do not fix"],"R_W":"Aristotle classifies the sources of apparent refutation, dividing them into those depending on language and those independent of it, and tests each against the definition of refutation. → identified twelve or thirteen fallacies (a numerical property of the text)","λ":[{"change":"he identified twelve or thirteen fallacies","lambda":4,"measure":"source fidelity"},{"change":"identified ... fallacies","lambda":4,"measure":"primary-text adequacy"}],"P_W":{"required":"inline citation (WP:V)","available":["https://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt","https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic/"]},"ρ_W":"The passages sent truncate S1 Part 4 before the list of language-dependent fallacies (offsets 6000-9000 missing, and the enumeration of the seven independent kinds is cut off), so the count of twelve or thirteen cannot be checked here. Wider S1 passages from Part 4 are needed. The Greek/Latin titles and romanization are not testable against S1/S2.","∼_W":"unimplemented: substitutability under WP:V is not computed","K_W":"unimplemented: the closure kind is not computed (S4 not run)","B_W":"unimplemented: S4's grammar ledger is not run","C_W":"unimplemented: talk-page and deletion pointers are not fetched"}},{"claim":{"id":"W2","section":"lead","text":"According to Aristotle, this is the first work to treat the subject of deductive reasoning in ancient Greece (Soph. Ref., 34, 183b34 ff.).","text_sha256":"c974b637f295bd5e7db92b9b16212592dbb809cdd6b0d610e470ff81145c3df6","footnotes":[],"pointers":[{"kind":"classical","work":"Soph. Ref.","chapter":"34","locus":"183b34","raw":"(Soph. Ref., 34, 183b34 ff.)"}],"cited":true},"ledger_key":"a877f4863fa55ca58789ea7a57d6ec2ccc46ad3efacb1833e63ef23356219791","sources":[{"ref":"S1","kind":"classical","pointer":{"kind":"classical","work":"Soph. Ref.","chapter":"34","locus":"183b34","raw":"(Soph. Ref., 34, 183b34 ff.)"},"edition":"Aristotle, De sophisticis elenchis","urn":"urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg040.1st1K-grc1","url":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/OpenGreekAndLatin/First1KGreek/7881c563436f52fb3550e6daa6df94be1b83b0e3/data/tlg0086/tlg040/tlg0086.tlg040.1st1K-grc1.xml","scope":"chapter 33","numbering":"cited chapter 34; this edition has 33 chapters, and its chapter 33 is the closing chapter","locus_note":"cited at Bekker 183b34; this edition is divided by chapter and section, without Bekker lines, so the whole chapter is the resolved source","retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:37.612Z","raw_sha256":"3d02be5360e529bcbb7502ae7c256f3b00ef6cc7d3ec894435cd2e481bee491b","text_sha256":"3a5aaa17de513d42b82d0cfc17af70bab8c47926f8c05cc59ea69d171499b9df","availability":"fetched","licence":"CC BY-SA 4.0 (First1KGreek); underlying edition public domain","located":"at the sentence","text_chars":6991},{"ref":"S2","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-SEP_AristotleLogic-2","citation":"Edward N. Zalta, ed. (18 March 2000). \"Aristotle's Logic, < Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy>\". Retrieved 2020-12-19.","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic","final_url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic/","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:39.078Z","raw_sha256":"f8f652676469b11b60256290204e2ebf81ed3d00ff3afcacf98d8e1063a0f365","text_sha256":"4bfff26b053e1b138c73ab3e81bde00f612918e7be45d0de6a623724a620dade","availability":"fetched","first_cited_at":"W4","located":"elsewhere in the article","text_chars":94132},{"ref":"S3","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-SEP_Refutation-1","citation":"Aristotle; Translated by W. A. Pickard-Cambridge. \"On Sophistical Refutations\". Retrieved 2020-12-19.","url":"http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt","final_url":"https://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:38.335Z","raw_sha256":"d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","text_sha256":"d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","availability":"fetched","first_cited_at":"W4","located":"elsewhere in the article","text_chars":130254},{"ref":"S4","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-Krabbe-3","citation":"Krabbe, E.C.W. (2012). \"Aristotle's On Sophistical Refutations\". Topoi. 31: 243–248. doi:10.1007/s11245-012-9124-0. hdl:11370/9e6b3574-e6b1-4b91-bbe4-78954ac9ea80. S2CID 170350834.","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007%2Fs11245-012-9124-0","final_url":"https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11245-012-9124-0","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:39.654Z","raw_sha256":"32ed63159c77e21ee19ca1b9aa3213ccf0218eb59539560b132a8e68ef0e18ea","text_sha256":"3930213bb30975ed5b9bf440d83a3a160dd698249a8beb71708c1adf0928fdc6","availability":"fetched","first_cited_at":"W6","located":"elsewhere in the article","text_chars":303}],"passes":[{"model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","reading":{"claim_id":"W2","innocent_reading":"The cited chapter says that for the method of syllogizing, nothing earlier existed ('περὶ δὲ τοῦ συλλογίζεσθαι παντελῶς οὐδὲν εἴχομεν πρότερον'), and that of this whole treatise 'οὐδὲν παντελῶς ὑπῆρχεν'. 'This work' is a natural shorthand for Aristotle's treatment of syllogizing (whether the Sophistical Refutations itself, or the Topics–Organon investigation of which it is the closing section), and 'in ancient Greece' is the only world Aristotle's pre-existing predecessors could inhabit. So the sentence is a defensible paraphrase of the closing claim of priority.","innocent_reading_fails_at":"The unit and scope: the source says the 'pragmateia' (the investigation of syllogizing, with the Topics' method and the closing recapitulation) had no predecessors, not that this particular 'work' (the Sophistical Refutations) is the first; and 'deductive reasoning' narrows the source's 'συλλογίζεσθαι' / 'συλλογιστικὴν δύναμιν' (a syllogistic faculty) in a way the Greek leaves broader or differently framed.","support":["partially-supported","interpretation-beyond-paraphrase"],"support_source":["at the sentence"],"spans":[{"quote":"περὶ δὲ τοῦ συλλογίζεσθαι παντελῶς οὐδὲν εἴχομεν πρότερον ἄλλο λέγειν","source_ref":"S1","role":"support"},{"quote":"Ταύτης δὲ τῆς πραγματείας οὐ τὸ μὲν ἦν τὸ δ᾿ οὐκ ἦν προεξειργασμένον, ἀλλ᾿ οὐδὲν παντελῶς ὑπῆρχεν","source_ref":"S1","role":"support"},{"quote":"Καὶ περὶ μὲν τῶν ῥητορικῶν ὑπῆρχε πολλὰ καὶ παλαιὰ τὰ λεγόμενα","source_ref":"S1","role":"contrast"},{"quote":"On Sophistical Refutations is a final section, or an appendix, to the Topics","source_ref":"S2","role":"scope"},{"quote":"According to Aristotle, this is the first work to treat the subject of deductive reasoning in ancient Greece","source_ref":"claim","role":"scope"}],"paraphrase":{"defensible":"Aristotle says that on the subject of syllogizing (reasoning by deduction) he had nothing earlier to draw on, and that none of this inquiry had been worked out before him; he contrasts this with rhetoric, which had many old treatments.","deltas":[{"sentence_says":"this is the first work","source_says":"this 'pragmateia' (inquiry/treatise on the method) had no prior work at all","kind":"scope","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":2},{"sentence_says":"the first work to treat the subject of deductive reasoning","source_says":"nothing earlier on 'συλλογίζεσθαι' (syllogizing); the inquiry is the dialectical-sophistic method of arguing and answering, not deduction in general","kind":"term changed","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":4},{"sentence_says":"in ancient Greece","source_says":null,"kind":"qualifier added","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":null},{"sentence_says":"According to Aristotle, this is the first work","source_says":"Aristotle's closing remarks survey the whole method (Topics through this book) as new; the Sophistical Refutations is, per S2, an appendix to the Topics","kind":"equivalence asserted","measure":"operative retention","lambda":2}]},"divided":[{"phrase":"this is the first work","readings":["'this work' = the Sophistical Refutations as a book: the source does not claim this, and S2 treats it as an appendix to the Topics","'this work' = the whole Organon-style inquiry into syllogizing culminating at this chapter: matches the source's 'ταύτης τῆς πραγματείας'"]},{"phrase":"the subject of deductive reasoning","readings":["syllogistic theory in the Analytics' sense","the method of arguing/refuting and answering on endoxic premises (dialectic and sophistic), which the source actually names as its subject"]}],"attributization":{"operation":"Aristotle claims, at the close of his treatise, that his inquiry had no predecessors and invites his audience to grant indulgence for its omissions and gratitude for its discoveries.","attribute":"first work on deductive reasoning in ancient Greece","value":"partial","reason":"The sentence turns an act of self-presentation (a claim of priority, tied to a request for indulgence) into a flat bibliographic property of a book, while keeping the 'According to Aristotle' frame.","surviving":["priority claim attributed to Aristotle","absence of predecessors in syllogizing"],"lost":["the contrast with rhetoric's many predecessors","the invitation to indulgence/gratitude","the recapitulative scope covering the whole method"],"converted":true},"retained_authority":{"value":"mixed","evidence":"The attribution 'According to Aristotle' keeps the claim in Aristotle's voice, so the reader can discount it; but the unit (this work) and subject (deductive reasoning) are the sentence's, not Aristotle's, and the hedge does not cover them.","revision_required":"State that Aristotle closes the treatise by claiming that the inquiry into syllogizing as a whole had no predecessors, in contrast with rhetoric, and ask his audience for indulgence for its gaps."},"invitation":{"codes":["omitted"],"qualification":false,"closure":true,"note":"The source ends by asking the audience to pardon omissions and be grateful for discoveries ('συγγνώμην ... χάριν'); the sentence reports the priority claim and drops that invitation, presenting it as a settled fact about the work (closure through attribution)."},"alternatives":["The sentence is a standard encyclopedic shorthand: the Sophistical Refutations is the Topics' closing section, and Aristotle's boast covers both, so 'this work' is acceptable.","'Deductive reasoning' is a fair gloss of 'συλλογίζεσθαι' and the 'ancient Greece' qualifier is harmless context."],"correction_pathway":"If a secondary source (e.g. Krabbe, S4, not retrievable here) states the same priority claim in these terms, the wording would be supported at one remove; a check of the Greek of 183b34–184b8 is needed to confirm that 'ταύτης τῆς πραγματείας' covers the Topics-plus-Refutations whole.","five_part":{"support":"S1 closes with 'περὶ δὲ τοῦ συλλογίζεσθαι παντελῶς οὐδὲν εἴχομεν πρότερον' and 'οὐδὲν παντελῶς ὑπῆρχεν', so a priority claim on syllogizing is directly supported.","changes":"The sentence makes 'this work' the unit, narrows/relabels the subject as 'deductive reasoning', and adds 'in ancient Greece'; it omits the rhetoric contrast and the closing plea for indulgence.","alternative":"Read 'this work' as the whole Topics–Refutations inquiry, which is what the Greek 'πραγματεία' denotes; then the change is only a loss of scope.","status":"Source support verified by quotation; the unit change inferred from S2's appendix description; the alternative reading contested.","revision":"Aristotle claims that his whole inquiry into syllogizing (Topics and Sophistical Refutations) had no predecessors, unlike rhetoric."},"needs_more_context":false,"policy":[{"clause":"Describing the information from cited material in one's own words while retaining the substance (i.e., not introducing ideas or arguments absent from the source)","status":"applicable"},{"clause":"Faithfully translating sourced material","status":"applicable"}],"notes":"Cited chapter is 34 in the Bekker/English numbering and the closing chapter (33) of this edition; the text read is the closing chapter, so the locus is resolved. S4 (Krabbe) returned only a client-challenge page and could not be read; S3 passages do not include chapter 34, so the English translation was not checked for this sentence."},"validation":{"ok":true,"breaches":[]},"usage":null},{"model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","reading":{"claim_id":"W2","support":["qualifier-added","partially-supported"],"support_source":["at the sentence"],"spans":[{"quote":"περὶ δὲ τοῦ συλλογίζεσθαι παντελῶς οὐδὲν εἴχομεν πρότερον ἄλλο λέγειν","source_ref":"S1","role":"support"},{"quote":"Ταύτης δὲ τῆς πραγματείας οὐ τὸ μὲν ἦν τὸ δ᾿ οὐκ ἦν προεξειργασμένον, ἀλλ᾿ οὐδὲν παντελῶς ὑπῆρχεν.","source_ref":"S1","role":"support"},{"quote":"According to Aristotle, this is the first work to treat the subject of deductive reasoning in ancient Greece","source_ref":"claim","role":"scope"}],"paraphrase":{"defensible":"Aristotle says that on syllogizing (and on this methodical treatment) he had no prior work to draw on, whereas rhetoric had much earlier material, so his own treatment started from nothing.","deltas":[]},"attributization":{"operation":"Aristotle reports that no earlier treatment of syllogizing existed for him and that his own work originated the discipline, contrasting it with rhetoric and the paid eristic teachers' ready-made speeches.","value":"partial","converted":true},"retained_authority":{"value":"mixed"},"needs_more_context":false,"notes":"The closing chapter does support Aristotle's priority claim about syllogizing and the method of this treatise, but the sentence recasts it as 'the first work' (a unit change from his claim about an undeveloped subject and method to a work), adds 'in ancient Greece' (a scope bound absent from the source), and cites '34' where this edition's closing chapter is 33; the attribution 'According to Aristotle' keeps it as his claim."},"validation":{"ok":true,"breaches":[]},"usage":null}],"verdict":{"status":"contested","differs":["support"],"invitation_differs":{"status":"prospective; recorded, not counted","readings":[["omitted"],[]]},"readings":[{"support":["partially-supported","interpretation-beyond-paraphrase"],"attributization":"partial","converted":true,"retained_authority":"mixed","paraphrase":"Aristotle says that on the subject of syllogizing (reasoning by deduction) he had nothing earlier to draw on, and that none of this inquiry had been worked out before him; he contrasts this with rhetoric, which had many old treatments.","changes":["this is the first work (source: this 'pragmateia' (inquiry/treatise on the method) had no prior work at all) · scope · source fidelity · λ 2","the first work to treat the subject of deductive reasoning (source: nothing earlier on 'συλλογίζεσθαι' (syllogizing); the inquiry is the dialectical-sophistic method of arguing and answering, not deduction in general) · term changed · source fidelity · λ 4","in ancient Greece · qualifier added · source fidelity","According to Aristotle, this is the first work (source: Aristotle's closing remarks survey the whole method (Topics through this book) as new; the Sophistical Refutations is, per S2, an appendix to the Topics) · equivalence asserted · operative retention · λ 2"],"innocent_reading":"The cited chapter says that for the method of syllogizing, nothing earlier existed ('περὶ δὲ τοῦ συλλογίζεσθαι παντελῶς οὐδὲν εἴχομεν πρότερον'), and that of this whole treatise 'οὐδὲν παντελῶς ὑπῆρχεν'. 'This work' is a natural shorthand for Aristotle's treatment of syllogizing (whether the Sophistical Refutations itself, or the Topics–Organon investigation of which it is the closing section), and 'in ancient Greece' is the only world Aristotle's pre-existing predecessors could inhabit. So the sentence is a defensible paraphrase of the closing claim of priority."},{"support":["qualifier-added","partially-supported"],"attributization":"partial","converted":true,"retained_authority":"mixed","paraphrase":"Aristotle says that on syllogizing (and on this methodical treatment) he had no prior work to draw on, whereas rhetoric had much earlier material, so his own treatment started from nothing.","changes":[]}]},"tuple":null},{"claim":{"id":"W3","section":"lead","text":"In it, he attempts to develop a pattern of sound and genuine reasoning in opposition to the deceptive or misleading \"art of sophistry\".","text_sha256":"28afc6baab33fcc638d25588cce512ec567f0a3464320c0e2ae0159f87c10d5a","footnotes":[],"pointers":[],"cited":false},"ledger_key":"360f0c55ca53d64fbb330fde0c956d9f33c9b4b759d7cf319024b239dcb6202a","sources":[{"ref":"S1","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-SEP_Refutation-1","citation":"Aristotle; Translated by W. A. Pickard-Cambridge. \"On Sophistical Refutations\". Retrieved 2020-12-19.","url":"http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt","final_url":"https://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:38.335Z","raw_sha256":"d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","text_sha256":"d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","availability":"fetched","first_cited_at":"W4","located":"elsewhere in the article","text_chars":130254},{"ref":"S2","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-SEP_AristotleLogic-2","citation":"Edward N. Zalta, ed. (18 March 2000). \"Aristotle's Logic, < Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy>\". Retrieved 2020-12-19.","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic","final_url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic/","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:39.078Z","raw_sha256":"f8f652676469b11b60256290204e2ebf81ed3d00ff3afcacf98d8e1063a0f365","text_sha256":"4bfff26b053e1b138c73ab3e81bde00f612918e7be45d0de6a623724a620dade","availability":"fetched","first_cited_at":"W4","located":"elsewhere in the article","text_chars":94132},{"ref":"S3","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-Krabbe-3","citation":"Krabbe, E.C.W. (2012). \"Aristotle's On Sophistical Refutations\". Topoi. 31: 243–248. doi:10.1007/s11245-012-9124-0. hdl:11370/9e6b3574-e6b1-4b91-bbe4-78954ac9ea80. S2CID 170350834.","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007%2Fs11245-012-9124-0","final_url":"https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11245-012-9124-0","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:39.654Z","raw_sha256":"32ed63159c77e21ee19ca1b9aa3213ccf0218eb59539560b132a8e68ef0e18ea","text_sha256":"3930213bb30975ed5b9bf440d83a3a160dd698249a8beb71708c1adf0928fdc6","availability":"fetched","first_cited_at":"W6","located":"elsewhere in the article","text_chars":303}],"passes":[{"model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","reading":{"claim_id":"W3","innocent_reading":"The Greek treatise contrasts genuine reasoning with merely apparent reasoning and defines sophistry as the semblance of wisdom without the reality. Aristotle's stated programme is to find a faculty of reasoning from generally accepted premises and to be able to examine others, and S2 describes sophistical arguments as only apparently establishing their conclusions. A lead sentence saying he sets sound reasoning against deceptive sophistry is a fair compression of S1 and S2 taken together, in the register of an encyclopedia lead.","innocent_reading_fails_at":"Only at 'attempts to develop a pattern of sound and genuine reasoning': S1's stated programme is a dialectical faculty of reasoning from generally accepted premises plus defending a thesis by such views, and the treatise is mainly about detecting and solving fallacies, not constructing a pattern of genuine reasoning. 'Pattern' and 'attempts' are the lead's own framing.","support":["partially-supported","qualifier-added"],"support_source":["elsewhere in the article"],"spans":[{"quote":"the art of the sophist is the semblance of wisdom without the reality","source_ref":"S1","role":"support"},{"quote":"That some reasonings are genuine, while others seem to be so but are","source_ref":"S1","role":"support"},{"quote":"Our programme was, then, to discover some faculty of reasoning about","source_ref":"S1","role":"scope"},{"quote":"arguments which only apparently establish their conclusions","source_ref":"S2","role":"support"},{"quote":"a kind of art of money-making","source_ref":"S1","role":"contrast"}],"paraphrase":{"defensible":"Aristotle distinguishes genuine from merely apparent reasoning and refutation, treats sophistry as an art of apparent wisdom for money, and aims to equip the reader to detect and answer such arguments while defending a thesis from generally accepted views.","deltas":[{"sentence_says":"he attempts to develop a pattern of sound and genuine reasoning","source_says":"Our programme was, then, to discover some faculty of reasoning about any theme put before us from the most generally accepted premisses","kind":"term changed","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":4},{"sentence_says":"in opposition to the deceptive or misleading \"art of sophistry\"","source_says":"the art of sophistry is, as we said, a kind of art of money-making from a merely apparent wisdom","kind":"scope","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":4},{"sentence_says":"attempts","source_says":"Of this inquiry ... Nothing existed at all.","kind":"hedge","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":4},{"sentence_says":"sound and genuine reasoning","source_says":"apparent but not real reasoning and refutation, with defence by generally held views","kind":"equivalence asserted","measure":"operative retention","lambda":4}]},"divided":[{"phrase":"in opposition to the deceptive or misleading \"art of sophistry\"","readings":["the treatise is polemically opposed to sophists and their teaching practice","the treatise equips the reader to detect and resolve sophistical arguments, a diagnostic rather than adversarial stance"]}],"attributization":{"operation":"Aristotle diagnoses the sources of apparent refutations, classifies fallacies, and prescribes how to question, answer and solve arguments, within a programme of dialectical examination.","attribute":null,"value":"no","reason":"The sentence states an aim and an opposition, not a property or category membership; the operation (diagnosis and solution of fallacies) is only gestured at.","surviving":["contrast between genuine and apparent reasoning","sophistry as deceptive"],"lost":["fallacy classification and solution","dialectical and examination aims","defence of a thesis from generally held views"],"converted":false},"retained_authority":{"value":"mixed","evidence":"The lead keeps the genuine/apparent contrast but compresses the treatise's diagnostic and dialectical function into a vague 'pattern' of reasoning; the article body presumably retains the detail.","revision_required":"Say that the work classifies the sources of fallacies and shows how to expose and answer them, as part of a dialectical programme."},"invitation":{"codes":["not-applicable"],"qualification":false,"closure":false,"note":"The source holds nothing out for the audience's judgment except the closing request for pardon, which a lead sentence need not report."},"alternatives":["The sentence is a defensible lead-level summary of the treatise's opposition between genuine and apparent reasoning.","Because the treatise ends by stating that its programme is to discover a faculty of dialectical reasoning, 'pattern of sound reasoning' could be read as that dialectical faculty."],"correction_pathway":"A cited secondary account (e.g. S3, Krabbe, unavailable here) stating the treatise's aim, or the article's body text on the treatise's contents, could confirm or revise 'develop a pattern of sound reasoning'.","five_part":{"support":"S1 opens by separating genuine from sham reasoning and defining sophistry as semblance of wisdom; S2 calls sophistical arguments only apparently valid.","changes":"Adds 'attempts to develop a pattern of sound and genuine reasoning' where S1 states a dialectical faculty programme; 'deceptive or misleading' stresses deception where S1 stresses apparent wisdom for money.","alternative":"The sentence is an acceptable lead compression; basis is the S1 opening contrast.","status":"Contrast with sophistry: verified by quotation. 'Develop a pattern of sound reasoning' as the treatise's aim: inferred, not verified.","revision":"Name the diagnostic and dialectical aim; or cite a source stating the treatise's purpose."},"needs_more_context":false,"policy":[{"clause":"Describing the information from cited material in one's own words while retaining the substance (i.e., not introducing ideas or arguments absent from the source)","status":"applicable"}],"notes":"The sentence is uncited; support is read from S1 and S2, cited elsewhere in the article. S3 did not load (client challenge) and is unresolved, so what Krabbe says about the treatise's aim is unknown. The sentence is a lead summary where source-text fidelity is loose but broadly sound."},"validation":{"ok":true,"breaches":[{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":0,"detail":"quoted span stands in S1 but not in the passages sent","quote":"the art of the sophist is the semblance of wisdom without the reality"},{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":2,"detail":"quoted span stands in S1 but not in the passages sent","quote":"Our programme was, then, to discover some faculty of reasoning about"}]},"usage":null},{"model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","reading":{"claim_id":"W3","support":["partially-supported","qualifier-added"],"support_source":["elsewhere in the article"],"spans":[{"quote":"Let us now discuss sophistic refutations, i.e. what appear to be refutations but are really fallacies instead.","source_ref":"S1","role":"support"},{"quote":"the art of the sophist is the semblance of wisdom without the reality","source_ref":"S1","role":"support"},{"quote":"to discover some faculty of reasoning about any theme put before us from the most generally accepted premisses that there are","source_ref":"S1","role":"contrast"},{"quote":"he also studies what he calls contentious ( eristikos ) or sophistical arguments: these he defines as arguments which only apparently establish their conclusions","source_ref":"S2","role":"support"}],"paraphrase":{"defensible":"In the work Aristotle sets out to analyse sophistical refutations, i.e. apparent but not genuine refutations, and to develop the ability to distinguish such sham reasoning from genuine reasoning and to defend a thesis without falling into them.","deltas":[]},"attributization":{"operation":"Aristotle diagnoses apparent refutations by classifying the sources of fallacy and gives methods for questioning, answering and solving them, within a programme of dialectic and examination.","value":"partial","converted":true},"retained_authority":{"value":"mixed"},"needs_more_context":false,"notes":"The sources support the contrast of genuine versus apparent reasoning and the 'art of sophistry' as a semblance of wisdom, but 'develop a pattern of sound and genuine reasoning' overstates Aristotle's stated aim, which is a faculty of dialectical argument from generally accepted premisses, and 'in opposition to' adds a framing not in the text; the sentence is uncited, so support is read from sources cited elsewhere in the article."},"validation":{"ok":true,"breaches":[{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":1,"detail":"quoted span stands in S1 but not in the passages sent","quote":"the art of the sophist is the semblance of wisdom without the reality"},{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":2,"detail":"quoted span stands in S1 but not in the passages sent","quote":"to discover some faculty of reasoning about any theme put before us from the most generally accepted premisses that there are"}]},"usage":null}],"verdict":{"status":"contested","differs":["attributization"],"invitation_differs":{"status":"prospective; recorded, not counted","readings":[["not-applicable"],[]]},"readings":[{"support":["partially-supported","qualifier-added"],"attributization":"no","converted":false,"retained_authority":"mixed","paraphrase":"Aristotle distinguishes genuine from merely apparent reasoning and refutation, treats sophistry as an art of apparent wisdom for money, and aims to equip the reader to detect and answer such arguments while defending a thesis from generally accepted views.","changes":["he attempts to develop a pattern of sound and genuine reasoning (source: Our programme was, then, to discover some faculty of reasoning about any theme put before us from the most generally accepted premisses) · term changed · source fidelity · λ 4","in opposition to the deceptive or misleading \"art of sophistry\" (source: the art of sophistry is, as we said, a kind of art of money-making from a merely apparent wisdom) · scope · source fidelity · λ 4","attempts (source: Of this inquiry ... Nothing existed at all.) · hedge · source fidelity · λ 4","sound and genuine reasoning (source: apparent but not real reasoning and refutation, with defence by generally held views) · equivalence asserted · operative retention · λ 4"],"innocent_reading":"The Greek treatise contrasts genuine reasoning with merely apparent reasoning and defines sophistry as the semblance of wisdom without the reality. Aristotle's stated programme is to find a faculty of reasoning from generally accepted premises and to be able to examine others, and S2 describes sophistical arguments as only apparently establishing their conclusions. A lead sentence saying he sets sound reasoning against deceptive sophistry is a fair compression of S1 and S2 taken together, in the register of an encyclopedia lead."},{"support":["partially-supported","qualifier-added"],"attributization":"partial","converted":true,"retained_authority":"mixed","paraphrase":"In the work Aristotle sets out to analyse sophistical refutations, i.e. apparent but not genuine refutations, and to develop the ability to distinguish such sham reasoning from genuine reasoning and to defend a thesis without falling into them.","changes":[]}]},"tuple":null},{"claim":{"id":"W4","section":"Overview","text":"On Sophistical Refutations consists of 34 chapters.","text_sha256":"43598d1bc76c5a7a18f10a27cd844ca50866a8d69ffc60c52c9eeb9aeab5c9cf","footnotes":[{"id":"cite_note-SEP_Refutation-1","text":"Aristotle; Translated by W. A. Pickard-Cambridge. \"On Sophistical Refutations\". Retrieved 2020-12-19.","links":["http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt"]},{"id":"cite_note-SEP_AristotleLogic-2","text":"Edward N. Zalta, ed. (18 March 2000). \"Aristotle's Logic, < Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy>\". Retrieved 2020-12-19.","links":["https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic"]}],"pointers":[],"cited":true},"ledger_key":"08e06d15282ea925073cf8b5301023fe4085624b9018e2c3d3333be472b0fdf6","sources":[{"ref":"S1","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-SEP_Refutation-1","citation":"Aristotle; Translated by W. A. Pickard-Cambridge. \"On Sophistical Refutations\". Retrieved 2020-12-19.","url":"http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt","final_url":"https://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:38.335Z","raw_sha256":"d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","text_sha256":"d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","availability":"fetched","located":"at the sentence","text_chars":130254},{"ref":"S2","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-SEP_AristotleLogic-2","citation":"Edward N. Zalta, ed. (18 March 2000). \"Aristotle's Logic, < Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy>\". Retrieved 2020-12-19.","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic","final_url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic/","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:39.078Z","raw_sha256":"f8f652676469b11b60256290204e2ebf81ed3d00ff3afcacf98d8e1063a0f365","text_sha256":"4bfff26b053e1b138c73ab3e81bde00f612918e7be45d0de6a623724a620dade","availability":"fetched","located":"at the sentence","text_chars":94132}],"passes":[{"model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","reading":{"claim_id":"W4","innocent_reading":"The cited translation (S1) is divided into 'Part 1' through 'Part 34', and the structure summary counts 34 Parts with max 34. Describing these Parts as 'chapters' is the ordinary English label for the numbered divisions of a classical treatise, so the sentence faithfully reports the work's division.","innocent_reading_fails_at":null,"support":["supported"],"support_source":["at the sentence"],"spans":[{"quote":"Part 1","source_ref":"S1","role":"support"},{"quote":"Part 8","source_ref":"S1","role":"support"},{"quote":"Part 9","source_ref":"S1","role":"support"},{"quote":"On Sophistical Refutations consists of 34 chapters.","source_ref":"claim","role":"scope"}],"paraphrase":{"defensible":"The treatise, in the Pickard-Cambridge translation, is divided into 34 numbered Parts.","deltas":[{"sentence_says":"34 chapters","source_says":"34 Parts (structure summary: Part count 34, max 34)","kind":"term changed","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":null}]},"divided":[],"attributization":{"operation":"The source divides the treatise into numbered sections (Parts 1 to 34); no argument or evaluative act is reported.","attribute":null,"value":"no","reason":"The sentence reports a structural count, not a credential, priority or category membership; there is no act to restate as a property.","surviving":["the number of divisions (34)"],"lost":[],"converted":false},"retained_authority":{"value":"retained","evidence":"A bare count of divisions leaves nothing for an operation to carry; the count matches the counted markers in S1.","revision_required":"None. If desired, 'Parts' could be used to match the translation's label, but 'chapters' keeps the substance."},"invitation":{"codes":["not-applicable"],"qualification":null,"closure":null,"note":"The source holds nothing out for the audience's judgment regarding the number of divisions."},"alternatives":["Other editions or translations may divide the treatise differently (e.g. the Bekker numbering counts 34 chapters, so no conflict is expected, but the cited source is the only division checked here)."],"correction_pathway":"A different standard division of the Greek text into other than 34 chapters, or a miscount in the structure summary, would revise this; neither appears in the supplied materials.","five_part":{"support":"S1's structure summary counts 34 Parts (max 34), and the passages show 'Part 1', 'Part 8', 'Part 9'.","changes":"The sentence calls the Parts 'chapters', a conventional equivalence that keeps the substance.","alternative":"A different edition could number the divisions differently, but the cited translation matches 34.","status":"Verified for source fidelity: the structure count of 34 Parts is checkable; the 'chapters' vs 'Parts' term is verified as a wording difference without change of substance.","revision":"A cited source showing a different number of divisions would revise this."},"needs_more_context":false,"policy":[{"clause":"Describing the information from cited material in one's own words while retaining the substance (i.e., not introducing ideas or arguments absent from the source)","status":"applicable"}],"notes":"Support rests on the code-counted structure summary (Part count 34) rather than on every Part appearing in the passages, which sampled only Parts 1, 8, 9 and the range between. S2 does not address the number of divisions; it is cited at the sentence but is not needed for this count."},"validation":{"ok":true,"breaches":[]},"usage":null},{"model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","reading":{"claim_id":"W4","support":["supported"],"support_source":["at the sentence"],"spans":[{"quote":"On Sophistical Refutations consists of 34 chapters.","source_ref":"claim","role":"scope"},{"quote":"\"Part\":{\"count\":34,\"max\":34}","source_ref":"S1","role":"support"},{"quote":"Part 8\n\nSince we know on how many points apparent syllogisms depend","source_ref":"S1","role":"support"},{"quote":"Part 9\n\nThe number of considerations on which depend","source_ref":"S1","role":"support"}],"paraphrase":{"defensible":"The cited Pickard-Cambridge translation of On Sophistical Refutations is divided into 34 numbered Parts, which the article's sentence calls chapters.","deltas":[]},"attributization":{"operation":"The source (translation) divides the treatise into numbered Parts, a count the sentence restates as a count of chapters.","value":"no","converted":false},"retained_authority":{"value":"retained"},"needs_more_context":false,"notes":"The structure summary counts 34 Parts with max 34, and the passages show Parts 1, 8 and 9 as division markers, so the sentence's 34 chapters matches the translation's 34 Parts (chapter and Part treated as equivalent division terms; the divisions are the translator's edition, not claimed to be Aristotle's own)."},"validation":{"ok":false,"breaches":[{"check":"quote-in-source","span":1,"detail":"quoted span not found verbatim in S1","quote":"\"Part\":{\"count\":34,\"max\":34}"}]},"usage":null}],"verdict":{"status":"single-valid","support":["supported"]},"tuple":{"ω":"The source divides the treatise into numbered sections (Parts 1 to 34); no argument or evaluative act is reported.","w":"On Sophistical Refutations consists of 34 chapters.","δ":"statement in Overview","G_W":[{"clause":"Describing the information from cited material in one's own words while retaining the substance (i.e., not introducing ideas or arguments absent from the source)","status":"applicable"}],"Δ_D":[{"sentence_says":"34 chapters","source_says":"34 Parts (structure summary: Part count 34, max 34)","kind":"term changed","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":null}],"Δ_C":[],"R_W":null,"λ":[],"P_W":{"required":"inline citation (WP:V)","available":["https://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt","https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic/"]},"ρ_W":"Support rests on the code-counted structure summary (Part count 34) rather than on every Part appearing in the passages, which sampled only Parts 1, 8, 9 and the range between. S2 does not address the number of divisions; it is cited at the sentence but is not needed for this count.","∼_W":"unimplemented: substitutability under WP:V is not computed","K_W":"unimplemented: the closure kind is not computed (S4 not run)","B_W":"unimplemented: S4's grammar ledger is not run","C_W":"unimplemented: talk-page and deletion pointers are not fetched"}},{"claim":{"id":"W5","section":"Overview","text":"The book naturally falls in two parts: chapters concerned with tactics for the Questioner (3–8 and 12–15) and chapters concerned with tactics for the Answerer (16–32).","text_sha256":"e2f5d3d5af93cc52c69bb4a70c43ca294a4a0004c1f351cc4ed862beb8bd314c","footnotes":[],"pointers":[],"cited":false},"ledger_key":"dc0335b5265c9045e4e510081d168809e85f856c102443eeea4bbfdd0a72263b","sources":[{"ref":"S1","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-SEP_AristotleLogic-2","citation":"Edward N. Zalta, ed. (18 March 2000). \"Aristotle's Logic, < Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy>\". Retrieved 2020-12-19.","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic","final_url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic/","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:39.078Z","raw_sha256":"f8f652676469b11b60256290204e2ebf81ed3d00ff3afcacf98d8e1063a0f365","text_sha256":"4bfff26b053e1b138c73ab3e81bde00f612918e7be45d0de6a623724a620dade","availability":"fetched","first_cited_at":"W4","located":"elsewhere in the article","text_chars":94132},{"ref":"S2","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-SEP_Refutation-1","citation":"Aristotle; Translated by W. A. Pickard-Cambridge. \"On Sophistical Refutations\". Retrieved 2020-12-19.","url":"http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt","final_url":"https://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:38.335Z","raw_sha256":"d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","text_sha256":"d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","availability":"fetched","first_cited_at":"W4","located":"elsewhere in the article","text_chars":130254},{"ref":"S3","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-Krabbe-3","citation":"Krabbe, E.C.W. (2012). \"Aristotle's On Sophistical Refutations\". Topoi. 31: 243–248. doi:10.1007/s11245-012-9124-0. hdl:11370/9e6b3574-e6b1-4b91-bbe4-78954ac9ea80. S2CID 170350834.","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007%2Fs11245-012-9124-0","final_url":"https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11245-012-9124-0","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:39.654Z","raw_sha256":"32ed63159c77e21ee19ca1b9aa3213ccf0218eb59539560b132a8e68ef0e18ea","text_sha256":"3930213bb30975ed5b9bf440d83a3a160dd698249a8beb71708c1adf0928fdc6","availability":"fetched","first_cited_at":"W6","located":"elsewhere in the article","text_chars":303}],"passes":[{"model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","reading":{"claim_id":"W5","innocent_reading":"The sentence is an uncited summary of the treatise's organization. Part 3 opens with the five aims of contentious arguers; Parts 12-15 treat drawing the answerer into fallacy/paradox/solecism/babbling via questioning, and Part 16 opens with 'next we have to speak of answering, and of how solutions should be made' (S2). So a Questioner/Answerer two-part division is a defensible reading of the structure, and the S2 text corroborates the break at Part 16.","innocent_reading_fails_at":"The chapter ranges and the 'naturally falls in two' framing are not verifiable from the supplied S2 passages (which sample only some parts and stop before Part 32's end), and the sentence omits chs. 1-2 and 9-11 and the concluding ch. 34 from its partition; the sources supply no explicit statement of the two-part division or the exact ranges.","support":["partially-supported","unresolved"],"support_source":["elsewhere in the article"],"spans":[{"quote":"next we have to speak of answering, and of how solutions should be made","source_ref":"S2","role":"support"},{"quote":"We have now therefore dealt with the sources of questions, and the methods of questioning in contentious disputations","source_ref":"S2","role":"support"},{"quote":"First we must grasp the number of aims entertained by those who argue as competitors","source_ref":"S2","role":"scope"},{"quote":"The book naturally falls in two parts","source_ref":"claim","role":"scope"}],"paraphrase":{"defensible":"Aristotle treats the sources of questions and questioning methods for the contentious Questioner, then, from Part 16, answering and solutions; Part 17 onward is thus answerer-side.","deltas":[{"sentence_says":"chapters concerned with tactics for the Questioner (3–8 and 12–15)","source_says":"Part 3 introduces the five aims; Parts 4-8 appear to survey fallacy types and their sources (the apparent-syllogism side), and Part 12 begins questioning for fallacy and paradox","kind":"scope","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":null},{"sentence_says":"chapters concerned with tactics for the Answerer (16–32)","source_says":"Part 16 states the turn to answering and solutions, but Parts 17-32 include the discussion of fallacy-by-fallacy solutions and Part 33 onward is not covered","kind":"scope","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":null},{"sentence_says":"The book naturally falls in two parts","source_says":null,"kind":"idea introduced","measure":"operative retention","lambda":null},{"sentence_says":"3–8 and 12–15 as the Questioner's tactics","source_says":"Parts 4-8 analyse the types and sources of fallacies and refutations, not tactics as such","kind":"equivalence asserted","measure":"operative retention","lambda":null}]},"divided":[{"phrase":"chapters concerned with tactics for the Questioner (3–8 and 12–15)","readings":["Chapters 3-8 are tactics for the Questioner (taxonomy of the means of apparent refutation, which a Questioner would use)","Chapters 3-8 are a diagnostic taxonomy of fallacies, relevant to both parties, with only 12-15 being tactics proper"]}],"attributization":{"operation":"Aristotle presents the aims of contentious argument and the sources of apparent refutation, then the manner of questioning, then the manner of answering and solving; the source performs an ordering of topics.","attribute":null,"value":"no","reason":"The sentence offers a structural summary of the work's organization, not a restatement of an act as a property or credential.","surviving":["order of questioning material before answering material"],"lost":[],"converted":false},"retained_authority":{"value":"unknown","evidence":"The partition is a modern editorial summary; the supplied sources neither confirm nor correct the chapter ranges, and the cited secondary source (S3) did not load.","revision_required":"Attribute the two-part division to a named commentator (e.g. S3 Krabbe) or hedge it as one way of dividing the work; note that chs. 1-2, 9-11, and 33-34 sit outside the stated parts."},"invitation":{"codes":["not-applicable"],"qualification":null,"closure":null,"note":"The source holds nothing out for the audience's judgment; the sentence only reports organization."},"alternatives":["Chs. 4-11 are a taxonomy of fallacies and refutations serving both parties, with only 12-15 as questioner tactics.","The work divides into three: aims and fallacy types (1-11), questioning (12-15), answering and solutions (16-33/34).","The two-part scheme is Krabbe's or another modern commentator's reading rather than a feature of the text."],"correction_pathway":"Read S3 (Krabbe 2012) to see whether it states the two-part division and these ranges; check the full S2 chapter headings (Parts 3-8, 12-15, 16-34) against the stated ranges.","five_part":{"support":"S2 supports a break at Part 16 (answering and solving) and a questioning discussion preceding it, but the exact ranges and the 'two parts' framing are not stated in the supplied passages.","changes":"Imposes a binary partition, assigns Parts 4-8 to Questioner tactics though they largely classify fallacy types, and omits Parts 1-2, 9-11 and 33-34.","alternative":"The work has a fuller structure (aims, fallacy taxonomy, questioning, answering, conclusion) and the Questioner/Answerer split is one scholarly reading of it.","status":"Break at Part 16: verified at S2. Ranges 3-8, 12-15, 16-32: unresolved. 'Naturally falls in two parts': inferred.","revision":"Cite the commentator (likely S3) for the division, or restate it as 'Chapters 12-15 concern questioning and 16-32 answering', and add the unclassified chapters."},"needs_more_context":true,"policy":[{"clause":"WP:V: any material challenged or likely to be challenged must be cited; an uncited structural summary is checked against cited sources elsewhere in the article","status":"applicable"},{"clause":"WP:NOR: describing cited material in one's own words while retaining the substance, not introducing ideas absent from the source","status":"applicable"}],"notes":"Passages supplied for S2 do not include the headings of Parts 4-11, 13-15, 17-31 or 33-34, so the chapter ranges cannot be checked; S3 (Krabbe) returned only a client-challenge page, so its content is unknown. The sentence is uncited, so any support is recorded as elsewhere in the article. A wider read of S2's part headings and S3 is needed."},"validation":{"ok":true,"breaches":[]},"usage":null},{"model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","reading":{"claim_id":"W5","support":["unresolved"],"support_source":["none"],"spans":[{"quote":"The book naturally falls in two parts: chapters concerned with tactics for the Questioner (3–8 and 12–15) and chapters concerned with tactics for the Answerer (16–32).","source_ref":"claim","role":"scope"},{"quote":"we have to speak of answering, and of how solutions should be made, and of what requires them","source_ref":"S2","role":"support"},{"quote":"First we must grasp the number of aims entertained by those who argue as competitors and rivals to the death.","source_ref":"S2","role":"contrast"}],"paraphrase":{"defensible":"Part 16 of S2 opens the discussion of answering and solutions, and Parts 3 onward treat the aims and methods of contentious questioners, so a broad questioner-then-answerer organisation is plausible, though the exact chapter ranges are not shown in the supplied passages.","deltas":[]},"attributization":{"operation":"The sentence describes the text's own organisation by dividing its chapters into questioner-tactics and answerer-tactics groups, assigning chapter ranges to each.","value":"no","converted":false},"retained_authority":{"value":"unknown"},"needs_more_context":true,"notes":"The sentence is uncited and S3 (Krabbe) failed to load, so the exact chapter ranges (3–8, 12–15, 16–32) and the 'two parts' framing cannot be checked, although S2's Part 16 passage supports the answerer-section start and the intervening Parts (9–11, 33–34) are not shown."},"validation":{"ok":true,"breaches":[]},"usage":null}],"verdict":{"status":"contested","differs":["support"],"invitation_differs":{"status":"prospective; recorded, not counted","readings":[["not-applicable"],[]]},"readings":[{"support":["partially-supported","unresolved"],"attributization":"no","converted":false,"retained_authority":"unknown","paraphrase":"Aristotle treats the sources of questions and questioning methods for the contentious Questioner, then, from Part 16, answering and solutions; Part 17 onward is thus answerer-side.","changes":["chapters concerned with tactics for the Questioner (3–8 and 12–15) (source: Part 3 introduces the five aims; Parts 4-8 appear to survey fallacy types and their sources (the apparent-syllogism side), and Part 12 begins questioning for fallacy and paradox) · scope · source fidelity","chapters concerned with tactics for the Answerer (16–32) (source: Part 16 states the turn to answering and solutions, but Parts 17-32 include the discussion of fallacy-by-fallacy solutions and Part 33 onward is not covered) · scope · source fidelity","The book naturally falls in two parts · idea introduced · operative retention","3–8 and 12–15 as the Questioner's tactics (source: Parts 4-8 analyse the types and sources of fallacies and refutations, not tactics as such) · equivalence asserted · operative retention"],"innocent_reading":"The sentence is an uncited summary of the treatise's organization. Part 3 opens with the five aims of contentious arguers; Parts 12-15 treat drawing the answerer into fallacy/paradox/solecism/babbling via questioning, and Part 16 opens with 'next we have to speak of answering, and of how solutions should be made' (S2). So a Questioner/Answerer two-part division is a defensible reading of the structure, and the S2 text corroborates the break at Part 16."},{"support":["unresolved"],"attributization":"no","converted":false,"retained_authority":"unknown","paraphrase":"Part 16 of S2 opens the discussion of answering and solutions, and Parts 3 onward treat the aims and methods of contentious questioners, so a broad questioner-then-answerer organisation is plausible, though the exact chapter ranges are not shown in the supplied passages.","changes":[]}]},"tuple":null},{"claim":{"id":"W6","section":"Overview","text":"Besides, there is an introduction (1–2), an interlude (9–11), and a conclusion (33–34).","text_sha256":"b97d9393cb8a881c727bdbd6693655fb1a9711cb2ac6b3bcfbec211e6383166a","footnotes":[{"id":"cite_note-Krabbe-3","text":"Krabbe, E.C.W. (2012). \"Aristotle's On Sophistical Refutations\". Topoi. 31: 243–248. doi:10.1007/s11245-012-9124-0. hdl:11370/9e6b3574-e6b1-4b91-bbe4-78954ac9ea80. S2CID 170350834.","links":["https://doi.org/10.1007%2Fs11245-012-9124-0","https://hdl.handle.net/11370%2F9e6b3574-e6b1-4b91-bbe4-78954ac9ea80","https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:170350834"]}],"pointers":[],"cited":true},"ledger_key":"6d581d9d04276e668b6432b7efa09dcd17e09f3572d59c08270576206bc2c97e","sources":[{"ref":"S1","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-Krabbe-3","citation":"Krabbe, E.C.W. (2012). \"Aristotle's On Sophistical Refutations\". Topoi. 31: 243–248. doi:10.1007/s11245-012-9124-0. hdl:11370/9e6b3574-e6b1-4b91-bbe4-78954ac9ea80. S2CID 170350834.","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007%2Fs11245-012-9124-0","final_url":"https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11245-012-9124-0","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:39.654Z","raw_sha256":"32ed63159c77e21ee19ca1b9aa3213ccf0218eb59539560b132a8e68ef0e18ea","text_sha256":"3930213bb30975ed5b9bf440d83a3a160dd698249a8beb71708c1adf0928fdc6","availability":"fetched","located":"at the sentence","text_chars":303},{"ref":"S2","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-SEP_AristotleLogic-2","citation":"Edward N. Zalta, ed. (18 March 2000). \"Aristotle's Logic, < Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy>\". Retrieved 2020-12-19.","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic","final_url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic/","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:39.078Z","raw_sha256":"f8f652676469b11b60256290204e2ebf81ed3d00ff3afcacf98d8e1063a0f365","text_sha256":"4bfff26b053e1b138c73ab3e81bde00f612918e7be45d0de6a623724a620dade","availability":"fetched","first_cited_at":"W4","located":"elsewhere in the article","text_chars":94132},{"ref":"S3","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-SEP_Refutation-1","citation":"Aristotle; Translated by W. A. Pickard-Cambridge. \"On Sophistical Refutations\". Retrieved 2020-12-19.","url":"http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt","final_url":"https://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:38.335Z","raw_sha256":"d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","text_sha256":"d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","availability":"fetched","first_cited_at":"W4","located":"elsewhere in the article","text_chars":130254}],"passes":[{"model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","reading":{"claim_id":"W6","innocent_reading":"The sentence is an uncited structural overview of the treatise's chapters: an introduction (chs. 1–2, which in S3 open the work, state its subject and distinguish four classes of arguments), an interlude (9–11), and a conclusion (33–34). The cited Krabbe article (S1) is presumably an overview of the treatise's structure, and the chapter numbers are checkable against the work itself.","innocent_reading_fails_at":"S1 is unreadable (a JavaScript challenge page), so the cited source cannot be checked. S3 passages cover chapters 1–4, 8–9 (part), 11, 13–14 and 15+ only partly, and nothing supplied shows chs. 33–34 or establishes that 9–11 is an 'interlude'; the labels themselves come from an interpretive scheme that no supplied source states.","support":["partially-supported","unresolved"],"support_source":["elsewhere in the article","none"],"spans":[{"quote":"Let us now discuss sophistic refutations, i.e. what appear to be\nrefutations but are really fallacies instead.","source_ref":"S3","role":"support"},{"quote":"Of arguments in dialogue form there are four classes:","source_ref":"S3","role":"support"},{"quote":"Client Challenge JavaScript is disabled in your browser.","source_ref":"S1","role":"scope"},{"quote":"Besides, there is an introduction (1–2), an interlude (9–11), and a conclusion (33–34).","source_ref":"claim","role":"scope"},{"quote":"Now for contentious and sophistical reasoning:","source_ref":"S3","role":"contrast"}],"paraphrase":{"defensible":"The treatise (34 chapters) opens with introductory chapters (1–2) before turning to the aims and kinds of sophistical refutation. The supplied S3 text confirms that the work has 34 parts and that Part 1–2 are introductory; chapters 9–11 and 33–34 can be located only by number, not by their content.","deltas":[{"sentence_says":"an interlude (9–11)","source_says":null,"kind":"idea introduced","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":5},{"sentence_says":"a conclusion (33–34)","source_says":null,"kind":"omission","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":5},{"sentence_says":"an introduction (1–2)","source_says":"Let us now discuss sophistic refutations... Of arguments in dialogue form there are four classes","kind":"none","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":null}]},"divided":[{"phrase":"Besides","readings":["Besides the core sections described in the preceding sentences of the article (a structural list, so 'besides' marks additional parts)","Besides the main body in general (the sentence frames an outline of the whole work around a body not named here)"]}],"attributization":{"operation":"The source (Krabbe) presumably surveys the treatise and describes its architecture; the sentence converts that scholarly description into a flat outline of labelled units.","attribute":"structural role (introduction / interlude / conclusion)","value":"partial","reason":"The sentence states the division as the article's own fact, with no attribution of the labels to Krabbe or to any outline, and the division is partly an interpretive scheme (especially 'interlude').","surviving":["chapter ranges for the introduction","the existence of a final chapter group"],"lost":["who proposes the division","whether the labels are Aristotle's or a scholar's"],"converted":true},"retained_authority":{"value":"unknown","evidence":"S1 could not be read, so whether its description of the structure can still revise this sentence is unknown; the sentence carries no attribution that would allow such revision.","revision_required":"If S1 gives a different division or different labels, the sentence should be reworded to attribute the outline to Krabbe and to match his terms."},"invitation":{"codes":["not-applicable"],"qualification":null,"closure":null,"note":"The source (as far as readable) holds nothing out for the audience's judgment; the sentence is a plain structural statement."},"alternatives":["The chapter ranges may come from Krabbe verbatim, in which case the sentence is a faithful paraphrase.","The 'interlude' label may be the Wikipedia editor's own synthesis from S3's content (chs. 9–11 are a digression on the examiner's and teacher's roles and on the limits of dialectic), which would be interpretation beyond paraphrase.","Chapters 33–34 may be a conclusion in Krabbe's account because ch. 34 contains Aristotle's closing remarks, a point S3 would settle if passages were supplied."],"correction_pathway":"Retrieve the full text of Krabbe (2012) and check his outline against the sentence; supply S3 chs. 9–11 and 33–34 in full to check what those chapters contain and whether 'interlude' and 'conclusion' describe them.","five_part":{"support":"S3 confirms that the treatise is divided into numbered parts and that chs. 1–2 are introductory; S1, the cited source, is unreadable, so the chapter ranges and labels are not verified.","changes":"The sentence assigns labels (introduction, interlude, conclusion) and chapter ranges without attribution; 'interlude' for 9–11 and 'conclusion' for 33–34 are not shown in the supplied text.","alternative":"The outline may be Krabbe's own, in which case the sentence is a faithful and adequately cited paraphrase.","status":"Introduction (1–2): verified from S3. Interlude and conclusion labels: unresolved. Attribution of the division: inferred missing.","revision":"Attribute the outline to Krabbe, or check S1 and revise the labels and ranges to match it."},"needs_more_context":true,"policy":[{"clause":"No original research: 'Describing the information from cited material in one's own words while retaining the substance'","status":"applicable"},{"clause":"Verifiability: the cited source must be checkable by readers","status":"applicable"}],"notes":"S1 returned only a bot-challenge page, so nothing in the cited source could be read; S3 passages skip many chapters, including 33–34 and most of 9–10. Wider passages from S3 (chs. 9–11 and 33–34) and a readable copy of S1 would settle the findings. The sentence is cited, but the citation could not be tested."},"validation":{"ok":true,"breaches":[{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":1,"detail":"quoted span stands in S3 but not in the passages sent","quote":"Of arguments in dialogue form there are four classes:"}]},"usage":null},{"model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","reading":{"claim_id":"W6","support":["unresolved"],"support_source":["none"],"spans":[{"quote":"Besides, there is an introduction (1–2), an interlude (9–11), and a conclusion (33–34).","source_ref":"claim","role":"scope"},{"quote":"Client Challenge JavaScript is disabled in your browser.","source_ref":"S1","role":"contrast"},{"quote":"Part 1 \n\nLet us now discuss sophistic refutations","source_ref":"S3","role":"scope"},{"quote":"SECTION 2\n\nPart 11","source_ref":"S3","role":"scope"}],"paraphrase":{"defensible":"The treatise is divided into 34 chapters, with a structural note that chapters 1-2 serve as an introduction, 9-11 as an interlude and 33-34 as a conclusion, as given by Krabbe.","deltas":[]},"attributization":{"operation":"The cited source (Krabbe) is said to describe the treatise's structure, assigning introduction, interlude and conclusion roles to chapter ranges.","value":"no","converted":false},"retained_authority":{"value":"unknown"},"needs_more_context":true,"notes":"The cited S1 (Krabbe) returned only a bot-challenge page, so the structural labels cannot be verified; S3 confirms 34 Parts and that Part 1-2 are introductory in content and Part 11 begins a new Section, but the 'interlude' and 'conclusion' characterizations rest on Krabbe, which is unavailable."},"validation":{"ok":true,"breaches":[]},"usage":null}],"verdict":{"status":"contested","differs":["support","attributization"],"invitation_differs":{"status":"prospective; recorded, not counted","readings":[["not-applicable"],[]]},"readings":[{"support":["partially-supported","unresolved"],"attributization":"partial","converted":true,"retained_authority":"unknown","paraphrase":"The treatise (34 chapters) opens with introductory chapters (1–2) before turning to the aims and kinds of sophistical refutation. The supplied S3 text confirms that the work has 34 parts and that Part 1–2 are introductory; chapters 9–11 and 33–34 can be located only by number, not by their content.","changes":["an interlude (9–11) · idea introduced · source fidelity · λ 5","a conclusion (33–34) · omission · source fidelity · λ 5","an introduction (1–2) (source: Let us now discuss sophistic refutations... Of arguments in dialogue form there are four classes) · none · source fidelity"],"innocent_reading":"The sentence is an uncited structural overview of the treatise's chapters: an introduction (chs. 1–2, which in S3 open the work, state its subject and distinguish four classes of arguments), an interlude (9–11), and a conclusion (33–34). The cited Krabbe article (S1) is presumably an overview of the treatise's structure, and the chapter numbers are checkable against the work itself."},{"support":["unresolved"],"attributization":"no","converted":false,"retained_authority":"unknown","paraphrase":"The treatise is divided into 34 chapters, with a structural note that chapters 1-2 serve as an introduction, 9-11 as an interlude and 33-34 as a conclusion, as given by Krabbe.","changes":[]}]},"tuple":null},{"claim":{"id":"W7","section":"Fallacies identified","text":"The fallacies Aristotle identifies in Chapter 4 (formal fallacies) and 5 (informal fallacies) of this book are the following:","text_sha256":"bfa263d4a059a82bd61b282b22cf92022d5b7baaac167f079578e0add0f47ab8","footnotes":[],"pointers":[],"cited":false},"ledger_key":"96ff979710960858bd85bb94044f1c9f8cbe52670f8cabc9c234cd77580a8cee","sources":[{"ref":"S1","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-SEP_AristotleLogic-2","citation":"Edward N. Zalta, ed. (18 March 2000). \"Aristotle's Logic, < Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy>\". Retrieved 2020-12-19.","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic","final_url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic/","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:39.078Z","raw_sha256":"f8f652676469b11b60256290204e2ebf81ed3d00ff3afcacf98d8e1063a0f365","text_sha256":"4bfff26b053e1b138c73ab3e81bde00f612918e7be45d0de6a623724a620dade","availability":"fetched","first_cited_at":"W4","located":"elsewhere in the article","text_chars":94132},{"ref":"S2","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-SEP_Refutation-1","citation":"Aristotle; Translated by W. A. Pickard-Cambridge. \"On Sophistical Refutations\". Retrieved 2020-12-19.","url":"http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt","final_url":"https://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:38.335Z","raw_sha256":"d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","text_sha256":"d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","availability":"fetched","first_cited_at":"W4","located":"elsewhere in the article","text_chars":130254}],"passes":[{"model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","reading":{"claim_id":"W7","innocent_reading":"Chapters 4 and 5 of On Sophistical Refutations do open the two lists (fallacies depending on language, then fallacies independent of language) that the article goes on to enumerate, and S2 divides them exactly that way. The sentence is a list-introducing frame; the list items it announces carry the substance, and the innocent reader takes the labels as a convenient shorthand for the two groups of fallacies.","innocent_reading_fails_at":"The labels 'formal fallacies' and 'informal fallacies' for Chapters 4 and 5. S2 divides the fallacies into those dependent on language and those independent of language, and never uses 'formal' or 'informal'. Chapter 4 also introduces both lists (the language-dependent set and the seven independent of language), and Chapter 5 begins the treatment of the independent ones, so the two chapters do not map onto a formal/informal division.","support":["partially-supported","interpretation-beyond-paraphrase"],"support_source":["elsewhere in the article"],"spans":[{"quote":"There are two styles of refutation: for some depend on the language used, while some are independent of language.","source_ref":"S2","role":"support"},{"quote":"Those ways of producing the false appearance of an argument which depend on language are six in number","source_ref":"S2","role":"support"},{"quote":"Of fallacies, on the other hand, that are independent of language there are seven kinds:","source_ref":"S2","role":"support"},{"quote":"Fallacies, then, that depend on Accident occur whenever any attribute is claimed to belong in like manner to a thing and to its accident.","source_ref":"S2","role":"scope"},{"quote":"formal fallacies","source_ref":"claim","role":"contrast"},{"quote":"informal fallacies","source_ref":"claim","role":"contrast"}],"paraphrase":{"defensible":"Aristotle, in Part 4, divides fallacious refutations into those depending on language (six kinds: ambiguity, amphiboly, combination, division of words, accent, form of expression) and those independent of language (seven kinds, beginning with accident), and Part 5 begins discussing the independent ones, starting with accident.","deltas":[{"sentence_says":"Chapter 4 (formal fallacies)","source_says":"Part 4: refutations that depend on language (six kinds), and a list of the seven kinds independent of language","kind":"term changed","measure":"primary-text adequacy","lambda":4},{"sentence_says":"5 (informal fallacies)","source_says":"Part 5 begins treating the fallacies independent of language, starting with Accident","kind":"term changed","measure":"primary-text adequacy","lambda":4},{"sentence_says":"Chapter 4 ... and 5 as two kinds of fallacy","source_says":"Part 4 itself lists both the language-dependent and the language-independent kinds; Part 5 is the start of the discussion of the seven","kind":"scope","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":4},{"sentence_says":"formal / informal as the dividing line","source_says":"dependence on language / independence of language","kind":"equivalence asserted","measure":"operative retention","lambda":4}]},"divided":[{"phrase":"Chapter 4 (formal fallacies) and 5 (informal fallacies)","readings":["Chapter 4 contains the formal fallacies and Chapter 5 the informal ones, each chapter corresponding to one category","The parentheticals are loose labels for the whole set of fallacies, with 'formal' meaning language-dependent and 'informal' meaning language-independent, the two chapters being only where the treatment begins"]}],"attributization":{"operation":"Aristotle divides the apparent refutations by the criterion of whether they depend on language, then enumerates the kinds under each head (six and seven).","attribute":"category membership: 'formal' vs 'informal' fallacy, tied to chapters 4 and 5","value":"partial","reason":"The enumerated kinds and the chapter location survive, but the dividing criterion is replaced by a modern formal/informal taxonomy absent from the source.","surviving":["the two groups of fallacies","their enumeration by kind","Part 4 and Part 5 as the loci"],"lost":["the criterion: dependence on language versus independence of it","that Part 4 contains both lists","the fact that the criterion is Aristotle's own division, not a formal/informal one"],"converted":true},"retained_authority":{"value":"lost","evidence":"The sentence presents the formal/informal division as Aristotle's own, tied to chapters, so a reader cannot recover that the source's dividing criterion is dependence on language; the source's own division no longer governs the description.","revision_required":"Restate the division in the source's terms: the fallacies that depend on language (Part 4) and those independent of language (Parts 4–5), or attribute 'formal'/'informal' to a named modern commentator."},"invitation":{"codes":["not-applicable"],"qualification":false,"closure":false,"note":"The source holds nothing out for its audience's judgment here; it classifies and enumerates."},"alternatives":["'Formal' and 'informal' are conventional modern labels for Aristotle's language-dependent and language-independent fallacies, widely used in textbooks, and the sentence only adopts that convention.","Wikipedia's other sentences in the section may already gloss the labels (the section list follows), so the frame is clarified at lambda 2."],"correction_pathway":"If the article's list items under this sentence, or a commentary source in the article, equate 'formal' with language-dependent and 'informal' with language-independent, the sentence would be a defensible gloss. S1 is a general entry on Aristotle's logic and is not shown to say this. A secondary source tying the formal/informal distinction to Aristotle's own division would revise the finding.","five_part":{"support":"S2 Part 4 divides fallacies into language-dependent (six) and language-independent (seven), and Part 5 begins the independent ones with accident.","changes":"The sentence relabels the division as formal/informal and assigns the two chapters to the two labels, though Part 4 holds both lists and the source never uses those terms.","alternative":"The labels may be a harmless modern convention for language-dependent and language-independent; basis: common textbook usage, not shown in S1 or S2.","status":"Verified by quotation that S2 uses a language-dependence division and not formal/informal and that Part 4 contains both lists; inferred that the sentence misassigns the chapters; unresolved whether another source in the article glosses the labels.","revision":"Rewrite as 'Aristotle divides fallacies into those that depend on language (Chapter 4) and those independent of language (Chapters 4–5)', or cite a source for the formal/informal labels."},"needs_more_context":false,"policy":[{"clause":"No original research: \"Describing the information from cited material in one's own words while retaining the substance (i.e., not introducing ideas or arguments absent from the source)\"","status":"applicable"},{"clause":"Verifiability: material should be attributable to a reliable source; a term not found in the source needs its own citation","status":"inferred"}],"notes":"The sentence is uncited; support is read against S1 and S2, both cited elsewhere in the article. The structure summary shows 34 Parts in S2; the passages contain Part 4 and the start of Part 5 only, which suffices for the division criterion. No passage of S1 addresses formal vs informal fallacies in Aristotle."},"validation":{"ok":true,"breaches":[]},"usage":null},{"model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","reading":{"claim_id":"W7","support":["partially-supported","qualifier-added"],"support_source":["elsewhere in the article"],"spans":[{"quote":"The fallacies Aristotle identifies in Chapter 4 (formal fallacies) and 5 (informal fallacies)","source_ref":"claim","role":"scope"},{"quote":"Those ways of producing the false appearance of an argument which depend on language are six in number","source_ref":"S2","role":"support"},{"quote":"Of fallacies, on the other hand, that are independent of language there are seven kinds","source_ref":"S2","role":"support"},{"quote":"There are two styles of refutation: for some depend on the language used, while some are independent of language.","source_ref":"S2","role":"contrast"}],"paraphrase":{"defensible":"Aristotle lists six language-dependent and seven language-independent modes of fallacious refutation, the first set given in Part 4 and the second set introduced at the end of Part 4 and developed from Part 5 onward.","deltas":[]},"attributization":{"operation":"Aristotle divides fallacious refutations into two styles, those dependent on language (six types) and those independent of language (seven types), and enumerates them.","value":"no","converted":false},"retained_authority":{"value":"mixed"},"needs_more_context":false,"notes":"The sentence is an uncited list-introducer whose enumeration is supported by S2 (6 + 7 kinds), but its labels 'formal' vs 'informal' (and 'Chapter 4 and 5') are not Aristotle's own division, which is language-dependent vs language-independent, and the seven independent fallacies are listed in Part 4 and treated from Part 5, so 'Chapter 5' does not map cleanly onto them."},"validation":{"ok":true,"breaches":[]},"usage":null}],"verdict":{"status":"contested","differs":["support","attributization","authority"],"invitation_differs":{"status":"prospective; recorded, not counted","readings":[["not-applicable"],[]]},"readings":[{"support":["partially-supported","interpretation-beyond-paraphrase"],"attributization":"partial","converted":true,"retained_authority":"lost","paraphrase":"Aristotle, in Part 4, divides fallacious refutations into those depending on language (six kinds: ambiguity, amphiboly, combination, division of words, accent, form of expression) and those independent of language (seven kinds, beginning with accident), and Part 5 begins discussing the independent ones, starting with accident.","changes":["Chapter 4 (formal fallacies) (source: Part 4: refutations that depend on language (six kinds), and a list of the seven kinds independent of language) · term changed · primary-text adequacy · λ 4","5 (informal fallacies) (source: Part 5 begins treating the fallacies independent of language, starting with Accident) · term changed · primary-text adequacy · λ 4","Chapter 4 ... and 5 as two kinds of fallacy (source: Part 4 itself lists both the language-dependent and the language-independent kinds; Part 5 is the start of the discussion of the seven) · scope · source fidelity · λ 4","formal / informal as the dividing line (source: dependence on language / independence of language) · equivalence asserted · operative retention · λ 4"],"innocent_reading":"Chapters 4 and 5 of On Sophistical Refutations do open the two lists (fallacies depending on language, then fallacies independent of language) that the article goes on to enumerate, and S2 divides them exactly that way. The sentence is a list-introducing frame; the list items it announces carry the substance, and the innocent reader takes the labels as a convenient shorthand for the two groups of fallacies."},{"support":["partially-supported","qualifier-added"],"attributization":"no","converted":false,"retained_authority":"mixed","paraphrase":"Aristotle lists six language-dependent and seven language-independent modes of fallacious refutation, the first set given in Part 4 and the second set introduced at the end of Part 4 and developed from Part 5 onward.","changes":[]}]},"tuple":null},{"claim":{"id":"W8","section":"Fallacies identified","text":"Figure of speech or form of expression","text_sha256":"a5cdcff7620ab7b29b5279822cd8361565bd71c3a534ef3324992f4a09aafdea","footnotes":[],"pointers":[],"cited":false},"ledger_key":"ec39f4b1511b0c54152226d4b68fbb4939bf3624d223eced8e3409a45b7780ee","sources":[{"ref":"S1","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-SEP_Refutation-1","citation":"Aristotle; Translated by W. A. Pickard-Cambridge. \"On Sophistical Refutations\". Retrieved 2020-12-19.","url":"http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt","final_url":"https://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/sophist_refut.mb.txt","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:38.335Z","raw_sha256":"d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","text_sha256":"d4708842c9d61156d4fe6ca39d1d7bdaa2f77e3f003c521f2ffabbbb2b23f6e3","availability":"fetched","first_cited_at":"W4","located":"elsewhere in the article","text_chars":130254},{"ref":"S2","kind":"footnote","note":"cite_note-SEP_AristotleLogic-2","citation":"Edward N. Zalta, ed. (18 March 2000). \"Aristotle's Logic, < Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy>\". Retrieved 2020-12-19.","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic","final_url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/aristotle-logic/","status":200,"retrieved":"2026-10-23T21:56:39.078Z","raw_sha256":"f8f652676469b11b60256290204e2ebf81ed3d00ff3afcacf98d8e1063a0f365","text_sha256":"4bfff26b053e1b138c73ab3e81bde00f612918e7be45d0de6a623724a620dade","availability":"fetched","first_cited_at":"W4","located":"elsewhere in the article","text_chars":94132}],"passes":[{"model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","reading":{"claim_id":"W8","innocent_reading":"The sentence is a list label in the 'Fallacies identified' section naming the fallacy Aristotle calls 'form of expression' (to schema tes lexeos), which the article's elsewhere-cited translation treats as one of the language-dependent fallacies; 'figure of speech' is the traditional English name for the same fallacy. As a heading-like label it asserts only that the fallacy is identified in the work under this name.","innocent_reading_fails_at":null,"support":["supported"],"support_source":["elsewhere in the article"],"spans":[{"quote":"the form of expression used, when what\nis really different is expressed in the same form","source_ref":"S1","role":"support"},{"quote":"With those\nthat depend on the of expression it is because of the likeness of\nexpression.","source_ref":"S1","role":"support"},{"quote":"Figure of speech or form of expression","source_ref":"claim","role":"scope"}],"paraphrase":{"defensible":"Aristotle identifies a language-dependent fallacy arising from the form of expression, where what is really different (a quality versus an action, masculine versus feminine) is expressed in the same grammatical form.","deltas":[{"sentence_says":"Figure of speech or form of expression","source_says":"the form of expression used, when what is really different is expressed in the same form","kind":"equivalence asserted","measure":"source fidelity","lambda":null}]},"divided":[],"attributization":{"operation":"Aristotle names a mode of fallacy in which different things are expressed in the same grammatical form and diagnoses it as one of the language-dependent sources of apparent refutation.","attribute":null,"value":"no","reason":"The label names a category of fallacy; it does not restate the source's act of diagnosis as a credential, priority or membership claim about a person or work.","surviving":["name of the fallacy","its place among the language-dependent fallacies"],"lost":["the diagnosis that different things are expressed in the same form","the examples such as 'flourishing' versus 'cutting'"],"converted":false},"retained_authority":{"value":"unknown","evidence":"The sentence is only a label and the cited translation supplies the full definition and examples beside it, so a reader can consult the source; whether the article elsewhere keeps that relation cannot be judged from the passages given.","revision_required":"None apparent for a list label; a gloss such as 'what is really different is expressed in the same grammatical form' would carry the operation."},"invitation":{"codes":["not-applicable"],"qualification":null,"closure":null,"note":"The source holds nothing out for the audience's judgment here."},"alternatives":["'Figure of speech' could be read in its modern rhetorical sense (metaphor, simile) rather than as a fallacy, which would mislead; the paired 'form of expression' disambiguates it.","The pairing 'Figure of speech or form of expression' may be taken as two rival translations of the Greek phrase rather than as synonyms."],"correction_pathway":"Checking the Greek 'schema tes lexeos' and other translations (e.g. Forster, Hamblin) for the conventional English name would confirm or revise the pairing; the supplied Pickard-Cambridge text already supports the 'form of expression' wording.","five_part":{"support":"S1 describes the fallacy as arising 'when what is really different is expressed in the same form' and names it 'the form of expression'.","changes":"The sentence adds the traditional alternative name 'figure of speech' not found in the supplied text and omits the definition and examples.","alternative":"'Figure of speech' might be read as the rhetorical device, not the fallacy; the conjunction with 'form of expression' makes the intended reading likely.","status":"Support for 'form of expression': verified by quotation. Equivalence of 'figure of speech': inferred (traditional name, not in supplied passages).","revision":"A source giving 'figure of speech' as a translation of the Greek term would settle the equivalence."},"needs_more_context":false,"policy":[{"clause":"Describing the information from cited material in one's own words while retaining the substance (i.e., not introducing ideas or arguments absent from the source)","status":"applicable"},{"clause":"Faithfully translating sourced material","status":"applicable"}],"notes":"The sentence is uncited at the sentence and was read against sources cited elsewhere in the article; support is recorded as elsewhere in the article. S1 passage text has a gap ('depend on the of expression') in the supplied copy, but the earlier passage on 'the form of expression used' suffices. S2 (SEP) does not address this fallacy in the supplied passages."},"validation":{"ok":true,"breaches":[{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":0,"detail":"quoted span stands in S1 but not in the passages sent","quote":"the form of expression used, when what\nis really different is expressed in the same form"},{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":1,"detail":"quoted span stands in S1 but not in the passages sent","quote":"With those\nthat depend on the of expression it is because of the likeness of\nexpression."}]},"usage":null},{"model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","reading":{"claim_id":"W8","support":["supported"],"support_source":["elsewhere in the article"],"spans":[{"quote":"Others come about owing to the form of expression used, when what\nis really different is expressed in the same form","source_ref":"S1","role":"support"},{"quote":"Figure of speech or form of expression","source_ref":"claim","role":"scope"}],"paraphrase":{"defensible":"Aristotle's language-dependent fallacies include one arising from the form of expression, where different things are expressed in the same grammatical form (e.g. quality by a quantity termination, or a state by an active word).","deltas":[]},"attributization":{"operation":"Aristotle names a language-dependent fallacy that arises when what is really different is expressed in the same grammatical form, and illustrates it with gender, quality/action and active/passive examples.","value":"no","converted":false},"retained_authority":{"value":"retained"},"needs_more_context":false,"notes":"The uncited list item 'Figure of speech or form of expression' is a standard label for Aristotle's fifth language-dependent fallacy, and S1 describes it as 'the form of expression used'; the 'figure of speech' wording is the translator-tradition label not found verbatim in this Pickard-Cambridge passage, but it is a defensible equivalent."},"validation":{"ok":true,"breaches":[{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":0,"detail":"quoted span stands in S1 but not in the passages sent","quote":"Others come about owing to the form of expression used, when what\nis really different is expressed in the same form"}]},"usage":null}],"verdict":{"status":"contested","differs":["authority"],"invitation_differs":{"status":"prospective; recorded, not counted","readings":[["not-applicable"],[]]},"readings":[{"support":["supported"],"attributization":"no","converted":false,"retained_authority":"unknown","paraphrase":"Aristotle identifies a language-dependent fallacy arising from the form of expression, where what is really different (a quality versus an action, masculine versus feminine) is expressed in the same grammatical form.","changes":["Figure of speech or form of expression (source: the form of expression used, when what is really different is expressed in the same form) · equivalence asserted · source fidelity"],"innocent_reading":"The sentence is a list label in the 'Fallacies identified' section naming the fallacy Aristotle calls 'form of expression' (to schema tes lexeos), which the article's elsewhere-cited translation treats as one of the language-dependent fallacies; 'figure of speech' is the traditional English name for the same fallacy. As a heading-like label it asserts only that the fallacy is identified in the work under this name."},{"support":["supported"],"attributization":"no","converted":false,"retained_authority":"retained","paraphrase":"Aristotle's language-dependent fallacies include one arising from the form of expression, where different things are expressed in the same grammatical form (e.g. quality by a quantity termination, or a state by an active word).","changes":[]}]},"tuple":null}],"breaches":[{"claim":"W1","model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","withheld":false,"breaches":[{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":1,"detail":"quoted span stands in S1 but not in the passages sent","quote":"Of fallacies, on the other hand, that are independent of language there are seven kinds"},{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":2,"detail":"quoted span stands in S2 but not in the passages sent","quote":"On Sophistical Refutations is a final section, or an appendix, to the Topics"}]},{"claim":"W1","model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","withheld":false,"breaches":[{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":0,"detail":"quoted span stands in S2 but not in the passages sent","quote":"On Sophistical Refutations is a final section, or an appendix, to the Topics"},{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":2,"detail":"quoted span stands in S1 but not in the passages sent","quote":"Of fallacies, on the other hand, that are independent of language there are seven kinds"}]},{"claim":"W3","model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","withheld":false,"breaches":[{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":0,"detail":"quoted span stands in S1 but not in the passages sent","quote":"the art of the sophist is the semblance of wisdom without the reality"},{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":2,"detail":"quoted span stands in S1 but not in the passages sent","quote":"Our programme was, then, to discover some faculty of reasoning about"}]},{"claim":"W3","model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","withheld":false,"breaches":[{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":1,"detail":"quoted span stands in S1 but not in the passages sent","quote":"the art of the sophist is the semblance of wisdom without the reality"},{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":2,"detail":"quoted span stands in S1 but not in the passages sent","quote":"to discover some faculty of reasoning about any theme put before us from the most generally accepted premisses that there are"}]},{"claim":"W4","model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","withheld":true,"breaches":[{"check":"quote-in-source","span":1,"detail":"quoted span not found verbatim in S1","quote":"\"Part\":{\"count\":34,\"max\":34}"}]},{"claim":"W6","model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","withheld":false,"breaches":[{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":1,"detail":"quoted span stands in S3 but not in the passages sent","quote":"Of arguments in dialogue form there are four classes:"}]},{"claim":"W8","model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","withheld":false,"breaches":[{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":0,"detail":"quoted span stands in S1 but not in the passages sent","quote":"the form of expression used, when what\nis really different is expressed in the same form"},{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":1,"detail":"quoted span stands in S1 but not in the passages sent","quote":"With those\nthat depend on the of expression it is because of the likeness of\nexpression."}]},{"claim":"W8","model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","withheld":false,"breaches":[{"check":"quote-outside-passages","span":0,"detail":"quoted span stands in S1 but not in the passages sent","quote":"Others come about owing to the form of expression used, when what\nis really different is expressed in the same form"}]}],"portable":null,"cost":{"seconds":274.662,"reader_usage":{"input_tokens":2068,"output_tokens":144260,"cache_creation_input_tokens":618408,"cache_read_input_tokens":489501},"actual_cost_usd":0.43268,"price_table":"claude-api-2026-10-21"},"billing":{"rule":"charged for completed claims only, at quoted per-claim prices; the rest of the reservation is released","cost_measured":true,"note":"the charge is shown to the buyer on the order's status (/v1/quotes/{quote_id}/status); it is not published with the result"}}